Image via The Baltimore Sun.
Image courtesy of The Baltimore Sun’s article on “WHEN GIRLS OF TODAY TAKE UP READING,” published 09.19.1915.

Over the weekend, I did some extended research on one of my favorite assigned authors – Mrs. Harriet Lummis Smith. According to a 1909 issue of The Sun, Mrs. Smith (also recognized as Mrs. William Mulligan Smith) was born in Auburndale, Massachusetts and was the daughter of Jennie Brewster Lummis and Dr. (and Reverend) Henry Lummis who had been the head of the Greek department at Lawrence College in Appleton, Wisconsin. She was also the sister of Harry Brewster Lummis and a half-sister of Charles Fletcher Lummis (who had been an author, adventurer and early advocate of multiculturalism). Charles F. Lummis’s mother had passed away at an early age, and his father (Reverend Henry Lummis at the time) remarried to Jennie Brewester (who also happened to be his teacher at the time of his father’s re-marriage who he had not established a warm rapport with. I found this to be a very interesting discovery… family drama!

Harriet Lummis Smith went on to study graduate at the University of Wisconsin after her mother and father had moved to Sheboygan, Wisconsin, where she went on to become a teacher of mathematics and Latin. After receiving a letter one day from a publisher who accepted a story of hers said that she was ‘wasting [her] time teaching,’ Mrs. Smith was given a final push to officially end her teaching career and pick up writing as a full-time profession. When she departed from teaching, she took up writing “merely for amusement” (The Sun, 1915).

Some time between the catalyst that sparked her career into writing and her time living on Calvert Street in Baltimore, Mrs. Smith received her A.B. (Bachelor of Arts) degree in 1886, and went on to accept a position at David Cook Publishing Company in 1894. Her sister Katherine went on to receive her A.M. degree (Master of Arts) at Stanford University in 1890 and then went on to study at the American School of Classical Studies in Rome (now known as the American Academy in Rome). Katherine later moved to Calvert Street also and lived close to her sister Harriet. Thank goodness for the Lawrence College Alumni Records! It is difficult to place when exactly Harriet had decided to go to move to Chicago. According to the February 14th, 1909 Baltimore Sun article, she had moved from Wisconsin to Chicago for some time where she then gained more of a reputation for her short stories to McClure’s Magazine, the Youth’s Companion, the Independent, Lippincott’s, and many more. I can only assume that she joined the WLCB by 1909 and ended her time at the WLCB soon after 1915 (according to club records), which means she must have moved to Calvert Street in Baltimore by 1909 since the Baltimore Sun biographical article had been published in 1909. Filling in the puzzle pieces is quite exciting!

While browsing the Minutes, I noticed that because she was referenced by her husband’s name, she would have gone by Mrs. William Mulligan Smith (she married her husband in Wisconsin in 1905) – but the Minutes label her as Mrs. William Milligan Smith in the 1909-1910 minutes! She had sat as Chairman and Judge of an election in 1909, and her name had been labeled properly as Mulligan at this time within the Minutes. During some instances, Mrs. Smith had been a substitute as the recording secretary in the 1910-1911 Minutes, and within the 1911-1912 Minutes, she continued to be a substitute Secretary for the Minutes. At the 779th Meeting on November 13th of 1913, as active Chairman, she had stated that, “while an autobiography is a man’s picture of himself as he likes to imagine he looks, his letters really reveal himself. The simple, almost stupid, letters of certain great men sometimes give us a feeling of affection for them not called out by their profundities” (“Other People’s Letters,” 779th Meeting); I found this comment by her to be particularly amusing as she opens up the Meeting with this comment. 1915 seemed to be the liveliest time for Mrs. Smith, as she went on to review many works within the club meetings, culminating with her election as President of the WLCB at the end of the season. After 1915, references to Mrs. Harriet Lummis Smith begin to taper off. With the 832nd Meeting’s text missing, it is difficult to try to understand what happened to Mrs. Smith from 1915-1916. Because these specific minutes are currently being transcribed, I will have to halt my research on the elusive and “Conspicuous” Harriet Lummis Smith!

..To be continued?!

Works Cited

“Guide to the Charles F. Lummis Papers.” Edited by Cyndi Shein and Michelle Weng, Online Archive of California, 2007, www.oac.cdlib.org/findaid/ark:/13030/kt9z09r4s7/entire_text/.
“Lawrence College Alumni Record, 1857-1915.” Google Books, 1915, books.google.com/books?id=i6ZEAAAAIAAJ&pg=PA248&lpg=PA248&dq=Henry%2BLummis%2BLawrence%2BCollege%2BWI&source=bl&ots=kESCF0OPlb&sig=CwtzBXwvpF5uGdkpcEwDjnQzUyA&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiDloOvvsHZAhUlhuAKHRZPC0kQ6AEILjAB#v=onepage&q=Lummis&f=false.
Reiche, Fanny K. “Baltimore Is The Home Of Many Conspicuous Woman Writers.” The Sun, 14 Feb. 1909, p. 17. ProQuest Historical Newspapers [ProQuest], search.proquest.com/docview/537631026?accountid=10750.
“WHEN GIRLS OF TODAY TAKE UP READING.” The Sun, 19 Sept. 1915, p. 1. ProQuest Historical Newspapers [ProQuest], search.proquest.com/docview/542626021?accountid=10750.
“Woman Novelist Dies in Philadelphia Home.” The Sun, 10 May 1947, p. 5. ProQuest Historical Newspapers [ProQuest], search.proquest.com/docview/542713608?accountid=10750.

4 thoughts on “Harriet L. Smith: A “Conspicuous Woman Writer”

  1. Hello,
    I have sighted Harriet Lummis Smith’s death certificate.
    I can tell you that her date of birth was 29 November 1866 and her date of death 9 May 1947.
    Her father’s name was Henry (you have him on your site as Harry which he probably was known as).

    I thought this may help you update your site a little, which I thoroughly enjoy.

    1. Thank you, Jen! (And apologies for the delayed response). We will certainly update Harriet’s bio. I’m curious to know where you happened to see the death certificate?
      Thank you for reading!

    1. Dear Jean Lee Cole,
      Hello! I am currently reading the book The Uncertain Glory, by Harriet Lummis Smith. I have only just begun reading, but within the first few pages, I find that I am thoroughly enjoying the writers style.
      I decided to look up more information on Harriet Lummis Smith so that I might find other books she had written and also, to learn a little more about her. While researching her name on Wikipedia, it described her as the “first black teacher in the Boston Public Schools.” ??? When I saw the picture posted of her, she did not appear to be black. Also within the article, there seems to be a description of a sister, and your article mentions only brothers.
      My question to you is could Wikipedia have confused Harriet Lummis Smith with someone else? A simple case of mistaken identity? The article Wikipedia cites describes her as “Harriet L Smith” not “Lummis Smith.” I mean absolutely no disrespect by asking, Im simply curious since the two articles do not seem to be describing the same person. ???
      I would love to get your opinion and possibly correct a simple (and honest, to be sure) mistake that may have been made. If I am incorrect, please forgive my ignorance and accept my apology for wasting your time.
      Kind Regards,
      Mrs. Angela Sgro

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *